Most Conservative Cities in Massachusetts
Massachusetts may be widely known for its historically liberal leanings, but it also has diverse political ideologies across its towns and cities. While liberalism dominates the urban centers and university towns, many other cities and towns in Massachusetts lean conservative, upholding values like fiscal responsibility, traditional family values, and limited government.
Let’s take a walk through Massachusetts from a conservative angle, then. Here, I’m going to guide you through the 14 most conservative cities in the state, counting down from number 14 all the way to the top spot at number 1.
And if you’re curious to see the flip side, exploring the most liberal cities in Massachusetts might just be your next read.
14. Whitman
Located in Plymouth County, Whitman leads our list. Renowned for its strong community ethos, this small town resonates with conservative ideologies. It has demonstrated an unwavering commitment to preserving its local heritage and fostering community development through initiatives like the Community Preservation Act, which allocates dedicated funding for conserving open spaces, historic landmarks, and affordable housing projects[14].
Whitman is a town that does not strongly support a single political party. Instead, its elections are closely contested, and both Republican and Democratic candidates receive significant support[15].
Despite this balanced political engagement, Whitman can still be characterized as leaning towards conservative values. The community places a high emphasis on family and fiscal responsibility. Residents actively engage in family-oriented activities, cherishing quality time with their loved ones. This sense of community and prioritization of family values is mirrored in the town’s approach to managing public resources and finances, highlighting a conservative approach to governance and social structure.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 40.9 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 15.3% (fewer seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (less than the national average rate)[1]
13. Saugus
Saugus is the thirteenth city on our list. It is a conservative city to the north of Boston. Its voter base has traditionally supported Republican candidates in state and federal elections[16].
Saugus strongly emphasizes community traditions and values. For instance, the town organizes communal celebrations such as the Hanukkah Menorah Lighting event, inviting all community members to participate in lighting the Menorah and celebrating together[17]. This illustrates the town’s commitment to inclusivity and cultural recognition.
My personal favorite spot is the Iron Town Diner on Main Street in Saugus. Walking into the diner feels like stepping right into the heart of Saugus’s community. Even with new owners, the diner’s charm and friendly atmosphere haven’t changed a bit. It’s a cozy spot that perfectly captures the town’s spirit, making everyone, locals and visitors alike, feel right at home. It’s a testament to the town’s commitment to keeping its traditions alive.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 45.2 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 20.9% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (less than the national average rate)[2]
12. Peabody
The city of Peabody, initially part of Salem and then incorporated as part of Danvers, was renamed in honor of George Peabody on April 30, 1868. This renaming was a tribute to Peabody’s contributions and his legacy as a philanthropist[19]. He is notable for his focus on educational and societal improvements that encouraged self-reliance and empowerment without promoting any religious or political agenda. That’s why I decided to include Peabody in this list.
Peabody has deep-seated conservative values due to its transformation from a farming community to an industrial powerhouse[18]. Hardworking people who exemplified fiscal responsibility and gradually developed a strong industrial base were the driving force behind this evolution. Peabody’s business leaders, known for their pragmatic approach, emphasized reinvestment, minimal debt, and community welfare, showcasing the city’s commitment to economic conservatism.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 47.0 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 24.2% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (less than the national average rate)[3]
11. Weymouth
Located within the metropolitan expanse of Boston, Weymouth stands out not just for its historical significance but for its distinct conservative leaning in a state known for its liberal ethos. At present, the city is led by a republican Mayor and attracts a demographic that values traditional family structures, community involvement, and fiscal conservatism[20].
This city, rich in neighborhoods that weave together a tapestry of tight-knit communities, prides itself on upholding traditions, promoting community cohesion, and exercising fiscal and governmental responsibility. Weymouth’s conservative identity is deeply ingrained in its community activities and the values it espouses. Events such as the Great Pumpkin Give-a-Wey are emblematic of this ethos[21].
To me, an event like this is far more significant than just an occasion for fun; it encapsulates the essence of what Weymouth represents. It is a community committed to family values, the importance of supporting one another, and the unity found in celebrating traditions.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 42.6 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 18.4% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.6% (more than the national average rate)[4]
10. Agawam
Agawam sits distinctively on the western edge of Massachusetts, embodying conservative values through its community ethos and governance. This city is known for its pragmatic approach to municipal management and a strong emphasis on family and community values, aligning closely with conservative principles.
Community engagement and traditional values are pillars of Agawam’s identity. The city hosts numerous family-friendly events throughout the year, such as the beloved Agawam SummerFest series, which fosters a sense of unity and belonging among residents[22]. These events are not just social gatherings but reinforce community bonds and uphold these conservative ideals.
Agawam’s conservative ethos is vividly reflected in its cultural pursuits, notably through the Agawam Cultural Council (ACC), a local extension of the Massachusetts Cultural Council[23]. This all-volunteer organization underscores the city’s commitment to fiscal responsibility and community values by funding arts and cultural events through state grants.
I’ve always been struck by Agawam’s profound respect for its own history and traditions. There’s a tangible sense of pride in how the city cares for its historical sites and landmarks, a clear homage to its rich past as it strides confidently into the future.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 45.2 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 22.4% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.4% (on par with the national average rate)[5]
9. Plymouth
Plymouth, famous for the first Pilgrim settlement, remains a beacon of tradition and conservative values rooted in its early American heritage. It stands as a vibrant testament to the lasting influence of its historical beginnings on its community and politics[24].
Plymouth’s demographics offer a window into its conservative leanings. With a population that skews older than the state average, Plymouth harbors a community with a penchant for traditional values. In fact, the town is actively working towards becoming an Age and Dementia Friendly Community[25]. This initiative focuses on understanding and improving the lives of older adults and individuals with dementia within the community.
From my perspective, Plymouth’s conservative stance isn’t merely about political leanings. It’s deeply intertwined with the city’s rich historical narrative, the distinct composition of its residents, and the core values that bind the community together. This unique blend gives Plymouth its characteristic conservative identity, making it stand out in the broader, more liberal landscape of Massachusetts.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 47.5 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 23.7% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.4% (on par with the national average rate)[6]
8. Billerica
Billerica shows a nuanced political landscape. While it leans towards Democratic in broader elections, it has a noticeable Republican voter base compared to nearby cities, and it’s been highlighted for its conservative political disposition. This mix illustrates a community that, while part of a predominantly liberal state, harbors a significant conservative sentiment, particularly when compared to its more liberal neighbors[26].
Billerica’s involvement in the Economic Development Tax Incentive Program demonstrates a conservative approach to economic growth, prioritizing private investment and local business support through tax incentives[27]. This strategy aligns with conservative values by fostering an environment where the private sector can thrive, emphasizing minimal government intervention and the importance of job creation and economic stability through business-friendly policies.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 42.1 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 16.6% (fewer seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (lower than the national average rate)[7]
7. Methuen
Methuen’s political and social landscape is also characterized by a strong inclination toward conservatism, a trait deeply woven into the city’s identity. This conservative stance is not just a political position but a reflection of the community’s values, traditions, and priorities.
At the heart of Methuen’s conservatism is a profound respect for traditional family structures, which are seen as the cornerstone of a healthy and stable society. Families in Methuen often exemplify a commitment to community engagement, moral values, and the nurturing of the next generation with respect for the past and a sense of duty towards the future.
Integral to this framework of values is the esteemed role of the Council on Aging, a body focused on delivering quality services to the city’s elderly residents[29]. The Council’s work is a testament to Methuen’s commitment to traditional family values and the principle of community responsibility towards its aging population.
The Methuen Festival of Trees, a long-standing community tradition, encapsulates the city’s commitment to its roots and community spirit[28]. Through the celebration of this event, residents come together to not only partake in the joyous season but also to reaffirm their commitment to communal values, historical preservation, and the fostering of a shared identity.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 41.5 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 17.7% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (lower than the national average rate)[8]
6. Marshfield
Marshfield, a coastal town on the South Shore, presents a politically active community with a blend of political affiliations. Recent voting patterns reveal a closely contested political landscape, with slight preferences in different elections[30].
The city values traditional American principles and community engagement, demonstrated through its dedication to veterans. Marshfield’s Department of Veterans’ Services exemplifies this commitment by actively supporting veterans and their families, ensuring they receive the benefits and respect they’ve earned[31].
During my visit to Marshfield, I was deeply impressed by the community’s respect for veterans. The town actively supports veterans with events, scholarships, and services, showing genuine gratitude for their service. This commitment highlights Marshfield’s strong community values.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 47.9 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 21.4% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (lower than the national average rate)[9]
5. Falmouth
Falmouth is a picturesque town on Cape Cod. The city prides itself on its maritime traditions, strong community bonds, and prudent fiscal policy[33].
The annual Falmouth Christmas Parade, a treasured community tradition, underscores these conservative values. Additionally, the Falmouth Republicans organization exemplifies the town’s conservative activism[32]. This group actively works to promote the election of Republican candidates across local, county, and state levels, further illustrating Falmouth’s conservative leanings.
I happened to assist a client in Falmouth. They are senior couples, and they heard that Falmouth has an inviting and serene environment, making it an ideal destination for senior couples looking for a tranquil place to settle. Falmouth’s charm is not just in its scenic beaches and lush landscapes; it also lies in its vibrant community spirit and the availability of amenities tailored to the needs of seniors.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 56.1 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 33.5% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (lower than the national average rate)[10]
We’ve also written an in-depth article covering some of the best places to live in Cape Cod, which Falmouth features. Take a look at which other places made our list here.
4. Bridgewater
Nestled within its borders, Bridgewater hosts Bridgewater State University, a vibrant academic community that adds a dynamic layer to the town’s otherwise conservative political climate. Bridgewater prides itself on a steadfast commitment to traditional values, an unwavering sense of community, and a prudent approach to fiscal management[34].
Bridgewater’s conservative ethos is further highlighted by its vibrant community spirit. The town hosts numerous events and gatherings that celebrate its rich heritage and foster a sense of belonging among its inhabitants. The “Bridgewater Arts and Music Festival” is a yearly celebration that highlights Bridgewater’s community spirit[35]. It brings residents together with live music, art shows, and fun activities for families, like face painting and crafts.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 37.2 (younger than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 15.2% (fewer seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (lower than the national average rate)[36]
3. Attleboro
At number three, we have Attleboro, a city known for its strong community spirit and conservative leanings. The city values tradition, fiscal responsibility, and limited government intervention. Attleboro’s support for conservative candidates in past elections confirms its conservative ideology.
In addition to its strong community and conservative values, Attleboro is home to a significant piece of history that embodies its respect for tradition and heritage: the Civil War Monument[37]. This monument is a powerful symbol of the city’s reverence for the past, honoring the bravery and sacrifices of those who fought in the Civil War.
Attleboro’s commitment to tradition is palpable in its community activities, local policies, and general public sentiment. This inclination towards conserving the past goes beyond mere nostalgia; it’s about preserving a way of life that values stability, respect for heritage, and a forward-moving yet cautious approach to change.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 41.7 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 16.3% (fewer seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.4% (on par with the national average rate)[11]
2. Leominster
In North Worcester County, Leominster stands out for its conservative values. Its history is deeply intertwined with the development of the plastics industry, a sector that propelled the city into economic prominence and innovation[38]. This industry legacy has fostered a culture of initiative among its residents, encouraging a spirit of entrepreneurship and self-reliance.
Central to Leominster’s identity is a strong emphasis on traditional family values, a testament to its conservative foundation. The city champions the importance of family as the core unit of society, advocating for policies and programs that support family well-being and community cohesion.
The Leominster Public Library adds vibrancy to the community, providing a vital resource for accessing information, especially for kids who can benefit from traditional modes of learning and exploration. It aligns with conservative values of education and heritage preservation[39].
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 40.9 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 16.9% (more seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (less than the national average rate)[12]
1. Bellingham
Topping our list of the most conservative cities in Massachusetts is Bellingham, a small town in Norfolk County. The town is steeped in a legacy of religious and political refuge that set the stage for its conservative ethos. This commitment is reinforced by its early fight for religious freedom, showing a dedication to core conservative principles[40].
Bellingham’s demographics and politics show its conservative tilt. Its older median age and support for Republicans reflect a community focused on tradition and family. Also, celebrating milestones like its founding’s 300th anniversary and 125 years of library services highlights its deep respect for history and tradition[41].
I was in Bellingham in 2017, and my impression was of a peaceful town. However, I noticed that people avoided talking about politics. It seemed like they wanted to keep things calm. Instead, they preferred chatting about sports and hobbies. But you could still sense that not everyone agreed on everything. Despite this, everyone seemed to try to respect each other’s views. It showed how much they valued getting along, even when politics caused uncertainty.
Overall, Bellingham is considered the most conservative city in the state due to its blend of historical reverence and community engagement. Its conservative nature is woven into the fabric of daily life. Bellingham not only honors its past but also paves the way for a future grounded in conservative values, making it a standout example of conservatism in Massachusetts.
Key Statistics (US Government Census)
- Median Age – 43.4 (older than the national average)
- Population Aged 65 or over – 16.7% (fewer seniors than the national average)
- Same-sex relationship status – 0.3% (less than the national average rate)[13]
Conclusion
Despite Massachusetts’ reputation for progressivism, it’s these conservative cities that contribute to the state’s rich tapestry of political and social thought. Recognizing and valuing these differing perspectives is crucial, as it fosters a culture of mutual respect and understanding.
By embracing this kind of diversity, people not only strengthen communities but also pull each other forward as a whole, indicating that there is strength and ability for shared progress.
Reference List
14 – https://www.whitman-ma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/2334/CPA-information-pamphlet
15 – https://www.whitman-ma.gov/ArchiveCenter/ViewFile/Item/279
17 – https://www.saugus-ma.gov/home/news/town-saugus-announces-hanukkah-menorah-lighting
18 – https://peabodyhistorical.org/history/
19 – https://peabody.jhu.edu/explore-peabody/our-history/george-peabody/
20 – https://www.weymouth.ma.us/mayor
22 – https://www.theq997.com/calendar/event/summerfest-at-school-street-park-in-agawam/
23 – https://www.agawamcc.org/
25 – https://www.plymouth-ma.gov/1096/Age-Dementia-Friendly-Community-Designat
26 – https://bestneighborhood.org/conservative-vs-liberal-map-billerica-ma/
27 – https://www.town.billerica.ma.us/257/Economic-Development-Tax-Incentive-Progr
28 – https://www.methuenfestivaloftrees.com/
29 – https://www.cityofmethuen.net/DocumentCenter/View/1273/Council-on-Aging-Bylaws-PDF?bidId=
31 – https://www.marshfield-ma.gov/veterans-services-marshfield
32 – https://www.falmouthrepublicans.org/
33 – https://www.falmouthma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/11214/Fiscal-Policy—2024-04-01?bidId=
34 – https://www.bridgewaterma.org/1434/Annual-Budget-Information
35 – https://www.bostoncentral.com/events/fair/p64036.php
36 – https://data.census.gov/table/DECENNIALDP2020.DP1?t=Same%20Sex%20Couples&g=160XX00US2508130
37 – https://www.cityofattleboro.us/524/All-About-The-Civil-War-Monument
38 – https://www.sciencehistory.org/stories/magazine/plastic-town/
39 – https://leominsterlibrary.org/about/library-policies
40 – https://www.bellinghamma.org/about-us
41 – https://www.bellinghamma.org/sites/g/files/vyhlif2796/f/uploads/2019annualreport_color.pdf
More Conservative City Articles
The 12 Most Conservative Cities in Georgia
